Visit Our New Paltz Community Apothecary
A doctor-curated space for high-quality herbs, supplements, and natural care. Located on the upper level of Water St Market.
This isn't just for people looking for a naturopathic doctor. If you're simply searching for a supplement store, you're in the right place too, no appointment needed.
Every product on our shelves is selected by Dr. Tonya Pasternak, ND, who has used these same lines in her own clinical practice for over a decade. That matters because dietary supplements aren't regulated by the FDA the way medications are. Any brand can put a product on a shelf without proving what's actually inside the bottle, and independent testing regularly turns up issues like inaccurate dosing or heavy metal contamination. Many of our products are pharmaceutical grade, USP certified, and third-party tested, so you're not left guessing.
Step Inside the Apothecary
What You'll Find In-Store
Hormone & Women's Health Support
Our most-asked-about category. You'll find hormone support formulas for menopause, mood changes, metabolism and libido.
Sleep, Stress & Everyday Relief
This is what most people actually come in for: something for the night they can't sleep, the anxiety that's flaring up, or the ache that's bothering them right now. Sleep support, anxiety support, and pain support are stocked front and center for exactly that reason.
Immune & Digestive Health
Immune formulas, digestive support, and protein powders for everyday wellness.
Seasonal & Everyday Wellness
Rotating seasonal picks like bug spray and allergy support, swapped in as the Hudson Valley seasons change.
Skincare
Clean sunscreens, organic tick sprays, skincare products, and essential oils. The things people tend to grab on impulse, all held to the same safety standard as everything else on the shelf.
Prefer to Order Online?
We use Fullscript to provide access to high-quality, physician-grade supplements from trusted manufacturers, carefully sourced and held to strong quality standards.
When you create a free account you’ll receive:
• Store-wide practitioner discount
• Access to professional-grade supplements
• Same-day shipping
• No membership or commitment required
3 simple steps:
Click Shop → Enter your email → Create a password
Every Product, Personally Approved
Dr. Tonya Pasternak doesn't just stock a shop, she vets it.
Dr. Pasternak reviews every product before it earns a spot on the shelf. She trained at Bastyr University and has spent over a decade in clinical practice, and she brings that same scrutiny to the apothecary that she brings to a patient's care plan. If a supplement doesn't meet her standard for quality, purity, and safety, it doesn't make the cut, no exceptions.
That's the difference between browsing a shelf and shopping one that's already been reviewed for you.
Find Us In New Paltz
10 Main St, Suite 423, New Paltz, NY 12561, on the upper level of Water St Market. Wellness Shoppe hours: Thursday to Saturday, 12pm to 5pm and Sunday, 11am to 4pm.
Frequently Asked Questions
No. The storefront is open to the public, and plenty of people visit just for the shop without ever booking a naturopathic visit.
Dr. Pasternak selects every product herself, and many are pharmaceutical grade, USP certified, and third-party tested for purity and potency. Since supplements aren't regulated the same way medications are, quality and dosing can vary a lot between brands. We stock what she'd feel confident using in her own practice.
Yes. Dr. Pasternak is in the shop regularly and can help you think through what might be a good fit, rather than leaving you to figure it out alone.
Most of our curated supplement lines are also available through our online Fullscript store, with same-day shipping and a store-wide practitioner discount for anyone who creates a free account.
Ready to See What's In Store?
Stop by the apothecary at Water St Market, or shop the full collection online with same-day shipping and a store-wide practitioner discount.
